They are not the same thing, and the difference is the whole point.
| Gloss | Dictionary extensions | |
|---|---|---|
| Tells you what the word means in this sentence | Yes — the meanings are ranked by the sentence | No — every meaning, in dictionary order |
| Shows the meaning you want first | Right about three times in four | You scroll |
| Shows an example of the word in use | Yes, from the dictionary's own examples | Sometimes |
| Synonyms and opposites | Yes | Sometimes |
| Works offline | Yes — the dictionary is inside | Usually yes |
| A reading mode that underlines the words you do not know | Yes | No |
you want a quick lookup of a word you half know, and you are happy to skim the meanings. They are good at that, and several of them are excellent.
you are reading something dense — a newspaper, a paper, a book — and the words you do not know are the ones whose meaning depends on the sentence. That is the case a dictionary popup cannot help with, because it cannot see the sentence.
Try it here — the demo is the real engine, and the word sanguine appears twice with two different meanings.